Top 10 Comfort Foods That Have Nothing to Prove

With all the AI-generated food photos these days and ongoing flood of TikTok hacks that defy basic cooking science, it feels like dishes are being designed for a camera rather than a fork. And it’s kind of bumming me out.

I can’t be the only one who’s in the mood for something a bit more … well, beige. Something involving potatoes, gravy or melted butter; dishes prepared with no interest in how it looks under a ring light. Comfort food, the food that’s been making people happy for generations without ever needing a makeover.

Here are ten of my favourite classic comfort foods. Not one of them has anything to prove.

1. Chicken pot pie

Is it still a pie if it only has pastry on top? Or does that make it a casserole in disguise? And should that topping be puff pastry, shortcrust or dumplings? People can argue about these things until the cows come home (or chickens, given the context). I’m less interested in that than I am in breaking that golden crispy topping up and mixing it into the creamy, unctuous (a word that doesn’t get used nearly enough these days) and decidedly unphotogenic filling beneath. It may look like a mess on the plate, but it’s delicious and that’s more to the point when eating.

2. Jacket potato

Crispy, salty skin; a soft, fluffy, gloriously carb-y interior and a flexibility when it comes to toppings that’s hard to beat. You might go for the simple pleasure of butter and cheese, dial things up a notch with bacon or mushrooms, or make a proper meal of it with chilli or baked beans. Perhaps you’re simply looking for a satisfying way to turn yesterday’s leftovers into tonight’s dinner.

jacket potato with butter and chives
Whatever you need from it, the humble jacket potato delivers.

3. Meatloaf

Meatloaf looms large in many American childhoods, although not always in a good way. Now as it happens, my mother made an excellent meatloaf, and if I went home tomorrow to find it on the dinner table, I’d be delighted. But I appreciate that not everyone’s experience was the same and so not everyone shares my enthusiasm. Some have memories of a mushy mess or a brick of mince topped with ketchup. And school lunches certainly have a lot to answer for. (What meat WAS that rubber rectangle made of, exactly?)

Look, we can all agree that meatloaf is never going to win a beauty contest. But a good meatloaf with the right mix of meat and a deeply satisfying browned crust against the sweetness of the glaze? Beautiful in its own glorious way, if you ask me. And as a major bonus, leftover slices make absolutely stonking sandwiches.

4. Beef stew

Beef stew occasionally features a bit of colour – a flash of orange carrot, a scattering of green peas. But let’s face it, the finished dish is essentially a bowl of brown but a deeply satisfying bowl of brown. And because a good beef stew takes its own sweet time cooking, the comfort begins hours before dinner, as the smell gradually fills the house. By the time it’s ready, you’re already looking forward to it.

5. Apple crumble with vanilla ice cream

First, a word about vanilla ice cream. If you think vanilla is boring, you’ve clearly never had a REALLY good vanilla ice cream and need a primer on vanilla. I will be taking no questions on this point.

apple crumble with a scoop of vanilla ice cream

Now, about the crumble. It’s all about contrasts. Soft, stewed apples beneath a crumbly (or crispy, if that’s your preference) topping. The tartness of Bramley apples against the sweetness of sugar and cinnamon. And, best of all, the temperature clash of hot crumble and cold ice cream. Of course, once the ice cream starts melting into the crumble, the whole thing becomes something of a visual disaster. But seriously – you aren’t shooting for Bon Appétit so who cares?

6. Macaroni and cheese

Nobody is going to argue that macaroni and cheese isn’t comfort food. What people – and by people, I mean me – will argue about is the freakshake-ification of this perfectly good dish in pursuit of social media attention. Comfort comes from a creamy béchamel sauce, plenty of good, strong cheese, a bit of mustard and a nicely browned or breadcrumb topping. I’ll even allow some crispy bacon or chopped chicken if you absolutely must. And I’m flexible about the pasta shape, provided it’s capable of delivering a generous helping of sauce.

a casserole dish full of classic macaroni and cheese

But lobster? Truffle oil? Barbecue sauce? Enough cheese to require structural reinforcement? Or so much smoked paprika that you can’t taste anything else? You do you. Leave my mac-n-cheese alone.

7. Shepherd’s or cottage pie

One thing I’m not going to argue about shepherd’s pie and cottage pie. I know the difference but for this discussion that difference is barely relevant as, from a comfort food perspective, they’re practically interchangeable. Both have been around for generations, bringing with them the reassuring familiarity of childhood dinners. And there’s something particularly comforting, especially when life feels a bit fraught, about knowing exactly what you’re going to get: minced meat, vegetables and gravy tucked beneath a generous blanket of mashed potato.

Nobody is going to mistake a generous scoop of either one for fine dining. But when life is complicated (as it seems to be these days for so many), there’s something extra comforting about dinner being so completely predictable.

8. Lasagne

Lasagne might just be the ultimate comfort food. After all, it’s essentially several comfort foods – pasta, rich ragù and melted cheese – layered together into one glorious dish. It’s made for sharing, whether around a family dinner table or with friends (another kind of comfort), and somehow manages to taste even better the next day (comfort that continues past meal time to the next meal time).

a slice of lasagne on a dark green plate

As for it’s appearance – sure, those perfectly constructed slices you may see in food photographs are lovely, they always look a bit too compacted or dry to me. There’s something I really relish about a generous helping of homemade lasagne that collapses into a delicious heap the moment it hits your plate.

9. Sausage and mash with gravy

Running the whole gamut from brown to beige, sausage and mash is a perfect example of why you should never judge a book by its cover. A really good sausage, gravy with a bit of punch (how much gravy is a personal decision I wouldn’t dare dictate) and a generous helping of fluffy mash to act as the delivery agent for the whole glorious mess. Perfection. Especially when the weather is miserable.

10. Hot buttered toast

Nothing could be simpler. And nothing belongs on this list more.

Bread. Salted butter. Done.

two slices of buttered toast

It’s quick, easy and capable of satisfying any number of cravings with almost no effort. And at the same time, it can be a ticket aboard the “Nostalgia Express”, taking you straight back to childhood breakfasts, sick days under the duvet or the cosy routines of quieter times. Proust’s madeleine has nothing on toast.

The choice of bread is entirely up to you, but there’s precious little that doesn’t benefit from being toasted and generously buttered.


None of these dishes needs a makeover, a clever twist or a moment in the social media spotlight. People have been making, sharing and enjoying them for generations and they’ll carry on doing so long after the latest food trend has disappeared.

Ten classic comfort foods. No makeover required.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *